The mastermind of the nation’s largest funding rip-off was 82
Bernard Madoff, mastermind of the largest investment fraud in US history that ripped off tens of thousands of customers valued at up to $ 65 billion, died on Wednesday. He was 82 years old.
His death at the Federal Medical Center in Butner, North Carolina has been confirmed by the Federal Bureau of Prisons.
Madoff died apparently of natural causes, the AP previously reported, citing an unidentified person who was familiar with the matter. He would have turned 83 on April 29th.
Madoff was serving a 150-year sentence in prison where he had been treated for a kidney disease that his lawyer had described as incurable. His request for a compassionate release from prison was denied in June.
Bernard Madoff leaves federal court in New York on Tuesday, March 10, 2009.
Jin Lee | Bloomberg | Getty Images
He pleaded guilty in 2009 to a plot that investigators said began in the early 1970s and defrauded more than 40,000 people in 125 countries in four decades when Madoff was brought to his knees on December 11, 2008 – after his two sons had given him up. Victims These included famous director Steven Spielberg, actor Kevin Bacon, former New York Mets owner Fred Wilpon, Hall of Fame pitcher Sandy Koufax and Nobel Peace Prize winner Elie Weisel, as well as ordinary investors like Burt Ross who lost $ 5 million .
Madoff insisted that the scam didn’t start until the early 1990s, when “the market stalled due to the outbreak of the recession and the Gulf War”.
In a 2013 email to CNBC from prison, Madoff claimed the market break that sparked the Great Recession led to his scam.
“I thought this was just a short-term trade that could be caught up again once the market became receptive,” he wrote. “The rest is my tragic story that I can never recover.”
In fact, according to investigators, Madoff has not executed a single trade for his advisory clients in years. Instead of using what is known as a split strike conversion strategy, as he claimed, he simply deposited the investors’ funds into a Chase bank account, paid off new customers with funds from previous customers – a pyramid investment strategy – and provided his customers with a fake account statement . The “returns” on the investment reported in these statements – around $ 50 billion in total – were pure fiction.
The Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities scandal shook investor confidence, which had already been damaged by the financial crisis. And it led to profound changes in the Securities and Exchange Commission, which missed the fraud for years despite repeated warnings, including from independent investigator Harry Markopolos, who set out to analyze Madoff’s improbable returns and found them fraudulent back in 2000 to explain.
An illustration of the Bernard Madoff Ponzi scheme, depicted as the “Joker” of Batman, can be seen on the cover of New York Magazine at a newsstand on February 24, 2009 in New York.
Timothy A. Clary | AFP | Getty Images
A subsequent investigation by the agency’s inspector general, H. David Kotz, found that SEC law enforcement officials decided to take Madoff’s word that his operation was legitimate rather than pursuing clear evidence of fraud.
“When Madoff gave evasive or conflicting answers to key questions on the testimony, they simply accepted his explanations as plausible,” Kotz wrote.
In early 2020, Madoff asked a judge to release him from prison. He was in end-stage kidney disease and too old to have a transplant.
“You know there has never been a day in prison that I did not feel guilty for the pain I inflicted on the victims and my family,” he told the Washington Post at the time. He said his goal was to explain his actions to his grandchildren.
“You know I lost both of my sons and my wife is not really well. So it’s terrible,” he told the Post. “I was very close to my family. I made a terrible mistake. And you know I suffer from it. I will suffer from it when I get out.”
But about four months later, a judge denied the motion, saying Madoff had “committed one of the most egregious financial crimes of all time” and “many people are still suffering.”
Bernard Lawrence Madoff was born in Queens, New York on April 29, 1938, to Sylvia and Ralph Madoff, a plumber who became a stockbroker.
Known on Wall Street for more than 50 years, Bernie Madoff was a great money manager who started his own company at the age of 22 and became the non-executive chairman of Nasdaq in 1990. He was credited with helping develop some of the systems and market structures that moved the stock market beyond the trading floor and resulted in modern electronic trading.
But Madoff’s life collapsed in the depths of the financial crisis in 2008.
Bernie Madoff is leaving Manhattan Federal Court in New York, USA on Monday, January 5th, 2009.
Jin Lee | Bloomberg | Getty Images
Madoff was inundated with redemption requests from his customers and could no longer sustain the fraud. On December 10, 2008, he confessed to his sons, Mark and Andrew, that the investment advisory business was a lie. Madoff had hoped to buy some time to distribute hundreds of millions of dollars in rewards to employees and then close the company. But Mark and Andrew, who were executives in the company’s trading business – which operated independently of the fraudulent advisory business – got none of it and alerted the local authorities.
A day later, on December 11, 2008, the FBI searched his offices in the Lipstick Building on Third Avenue in Midtown Manhattan.
On March 12, 2009, Madoff pleaded guilty to eleven federal crimes and admitted running the largest private Ponzi program in history. Three months later, he was sentenced to a maximum sentence of 150 years in prison with a refund of $ 170 billion.
In court, he insisted that it was all his idea – that his family knew nothing – even though his wife Ruth had once kept the books, his sons were senior executives, and his younger brother Peter was the chief compliance officer. Charles Spada, an attorney for Peter Madoff, declined to comment on Wednesday.
Andrew Madoff sits between his girlfriend Catherine Hooper and mother Ruth Madoff as he appears on NBC’s “TODAY” show in 2011.
Peter Kramer | NBC NewsWire | Getty Images
However, a trustee hired to track down funds for investors did not buy them. Irving H. Picard sued dozens of people and organizations, including Madoff’s family members, claiming they either knew of the scam or turned a blind eye while it generated millions of dollars in benefits.
The suspicion was too great for the older son Mark. In 2010, two years before the day of his father’s arrest, he became the third suicide-related fraud. He was 46 years old. Four years later, Andrew died of lymphoma at the age of 48.
Picard eventually reached settlements with the sons’ estates and with Ruth Madoff, who continues to deny any knowledge of the fraud and reportedly lives humbly in Connecticut.
In the end, more than a dozen people, including Peter Madoff, were convicted of federal crimes in addition to Madoff, but none of the others were charged with knowing about the fraud. JPMorgan Chase, Madoff’s main bank, paid $ 2.6 billion to the US government and Madoff victims in 2014 to clarify allegations that it was not maintaining adequate controls. After Chase initiated some unspecified reforms, prosecutors dropped charges against the bank.
Medical examiners remove Mark Madoff’s body from his New York apartment on December 11, 2010.
Emmanuel Dunnand | AFP | Getty Images
According to former SEC chairman Richard C. Breeden, special master of the fund, the Madoff Victim Fund paid nearly 37,000 victims on Wednesday, most of whom are making up 80% of their losses. That’s a number that is usually unknown in a Ponzi scheme.
“Aside from losing tens of billions of dollars, the human consequences of the crime were almost incalculable,” Breeden said in a statement. “Many victims could no longer live independently, meet health needs for themselves or a spouse, care for children or grandchildren, or otherwise provide for basic needs. Many victims were not rich and, for many, the loss of all or a significant part of themselves Victim life savings had brutal effects. “
“The pain suffered by Mr Madoff’s fraud victims is not lessened by his death, and our work for his victims is not finished,” Picard said in a statement Wednesday. “My legal team and I are committed to continuing to identify, recover and return Mr. Madoff’s stolen funds to their rightful owners.”
While in jail, Madoff tried repeatedly to have the recoveries recognized, claiming he had pressured his biggest investors to return some of their money.
“These parties were well aware of the incriminating evidence I possessed of their complicit activities and have deliberately presented settlements,” he wrote in 2013.
But Picard and federal investigators said Madoff never provided them any useful help. The remorse he claimed in every message was also suspect. When convicted in 2009, Madoff turned to his victims. “I’m sorry,” he said. “I know that won’t help you.”
It was not like that.
Cheers broke out as Federal Judge Denny Chin ordered the maximum sentence for “extraordinarily evil” crimes.
Ross, a former Fort Lee, New Jersey mayor who testified at the hearing, told Chin: “Put Madoff in jail for the rest of his life. May Satan grow a fourth mouth in which Madoff can spend the rest of eternity . “
In an email to CNBC on Wednesday, Madoff’s chief prosecutor Marc Litt said, “It is sadly fitting that he died in prison.”
“I believe I speak for the team that prosecuted Mr. Madoff and his staff when I say his death closes a dark chapter of deception and greed that has irreversibly damaged the lives of tens of thousands of victims,” Litt said who is now in private practice. “From start to finish, this episode brought nothing but devastation to everyone he touched.”
Madoff’s attorney for the past few years, Brandon Sample, said in an email on Wednesday that his client “lived with guilt and remorse for his crimes until his death. Although the crimes for which Bernie was convicted have come, to define who he was – so was he. ” a father and a husband. He spoke softly and was an intellectual. Bernie was by no means perfect. But it is not a man. “
Breeden said: “Unfortunately, no one can eradicate the victims of fear or restore the years that their lives were badly affected. It is important that we never forget what Madoff did to prevent it from happening again.”
– CNBC’s Jim Forkin contributed to this report.