He returned a PPP mortgage, hoping for more cash. Then this system ended
Carmelo Ramos returned his $ 11,458 PPP loan because he qualified for more cash. He was left with nothing when the program ran out of funds when he reapplied.
When 36-year-old Carmelo Ramos received his second paycheck protection loan in February, he was grateful.
The $ 11,458 loan was more than the roughly $ 6,200 he received in the first round of the program in 2020. While it didn’t cover all of the business that had lost its training advice due to the coronavirus pandemic, it helped.
Then his personal commercial banker at Capital One told him he could get even more money – an additional $ 7,000 – if he returned his loan and applied for again.
More from Invest in You:
New monthly child tax credits begin July 15th. What you should know
Small business owners were blind when PPP funding ran out prematurely
This is how you receive the monthly tax credit for children if you do not have a permanent address
He chose to do it, but was left with nothing when the program ran out of money in early May, weeks before the deadline.
“The money I would have received would have made a difference,” said Ramos, adding that it covered his pay. He also planned to invest part of the loan in new marketing materials.
Smallest companies unprepared
Ramos was one of millions of business owners in the pipeline in early May when the PPP suddenly ran out of its allotted $ 292 billion.
Ramos has been hit especially hard for being a sole proprietor, one of the smallest types of businesses, and a group specifically focused on the recent changes to the Small Business Administration program.
“I think we had finally gone around the corner and gained significant awareness in the communities we target, especially in very small businesses and minorities,” said Toby Scammell, founder and CEO of Womply, a fintech Company that matches borrowers with lenders.
Womply saw that in the last few weeks of the program, more of the smallest companies, more belonging to minorities and women, applied. Fast lane applications for such companies received about 1,000 applications per day in the week leading up to the end of funding, Scammel said.
Changes came at the last minute
In February, the Biden administration made changes to PPP, including updating the sole proprietorship loan formula, resulting in larger loans.
The maximum PPP loans for companies with employees were calculated using 2.5 times the average monthly wage and salary costs. For companies without employees, such as sole proprietorships and independent contractors, the SBA used net profit as a substitute for labor costs. Because this measure included deductions, it resulted in smaller loans and even made some ineligible.
Instead, the new formula used gross income to replace labor costs, a larger number that does not include any deductions. That meant companies that applied under the new rule got more money for forgivable loans.
To Ramos, the additional $ 7,000 seemed worth the risk of canceling his existing loan and trying again. It was March when he started the cancellation process – months before the May 31 extended program date.
“The reason I chose to do this is because it’s the difference between being able to hike for another five to ten months,” he said.
However, the process took longer than expected. At first, Ramos received a promissory note for his new loan, but it was the old amount – meaning it hadn’t been calculated using the new formula.
While trying to figure out what to do with Capital One, the program ran out of money and he ran out of credit at all.
“Unfortunately, the Paycheck Protection Program for large financial institutions ran out of funds well before May 31, and we know that many small business owners across the country were taken by surprise by the sudden timing,” Capital One said in a statement it emailed.
Other options for small businesses at risk
When the PPP ended, around $ 9 billion was earmarked for borrowers who applied through financial institutions in the community. Most of the money has run out, however – around $ 6.5 billion has been lent through community financial institutions in the past few weeks, leaving around $ 2.5 billion in the program, according to the SBA.
Many lenders encourage entrenched applicants to reapply with these companies, but it’s easier said than done. Ramos said he had spent hours trying to find a financial institution in the community to apply to, but failed to find a new financial institution.
There are a few other small business programs hard hit by the coronavirus pandemic, such as the SBA Economic Injury Loan Program, the Shuttered Venue Operators Grant Program, and the Restaurant Revitalization Fund.
However, some of these programs do not have sufficient funding. For example, more than 266,000 companies applied for the $ 28 billion Restaurant Revitalization Fund in the first few weeks.
“We believe this program will be oversubscribed and if we can cover all of the eligible restaurants, Congress needs to put more money into this program,” Senator Ben Cardin, D-Md., Said during an event with Small on Thursday Business Majority, an advocacy group. “It has yet to be determined by Congress, but we need to put more money into this program.”
PPP would also need more money allocated by Congress to meet the need, Cardin said, especially for sole proprietorships. Some small businesses have missed large amounts of credit because they applied before new rules came into effect and since the beginning of the year they have been demanding that those rules be retroactive. Cardin has introduced laws for this.
“We think laws should be passed,” he said. “In addition to changing this bill to make it retroactive, we would also have to apply some additional funding.”
SIGN IN: Money 101 is an 8-week financial freedom learning course delivered to your inbox weekly.
CHECK OUT: How to make money doing creative side businesses, from people who make over thousands on sites like Etsy and Twitch Grow with acorns + CNBC.
Disclosure: NBCUniversal and Comcast Ventures are investors in Acorns.